How to Make Sure Tough Feedback Is Heard the Way You Mean It
Connect through empathy during challenging leadership discussions
You can walk into a tough conversation fully prepared, say exactly what you planned, and still have the other person walk out having heard something else entirely.
Last week I wrote about why leaders put off tough conversations and the reasons we give ourselves for waiting. Once you decide to have the conversation, a different challenge shows up. You can walk in prepared, say exactly what you planned to say, and still have the other person leave having heard something completely different. That gap usually comes from what the other person is trying to figure out while you are talking.
Every conversation has three layers
Charles Duhigg's book Supercommunicators offers a useful way to think about this. Most conversations have a practical part, an emotional part, and a social part. The practical question is, "What happened, and what needs to change?" The emotional question is, "How does this feel?" The social question is, "What does this say about me, my role, or my relationship with you?"
A tough conversation can move through all three in a matter of minutes. You may be talking about a missed commitment, while the other person is trying to figure out whether you still trust them. If you only answer the practical question, you may never get through to the person who is trying to answer the social one.
The same words can be heard two ways
Trust has a lot to do with which conversation the other person thinks they are in. If someone already trusts you, they may hear coaching feedback and think, "I trust this person. They are not yelling at me or getting ready to fire me. They are trying to help me get better."
Someone who does not know where they stand with you may hear the same words very differently. You say, "What you did here is not what we are looking for. I need you to do this instead." They hear, "I am not good enough. I might be in serious trouble. I might get fired, and I do not even know what I am supposed to do now."
Once that happens, the message is no longer reaching the person the way you intended. You walk away thinking you explained exactly what they need to do better. They walk away wondering whether their job is in danger. You were having a practical conversation. They were having a social one about whether they still belong.
Match your approach to the relationship
That does not mean you have to spend half an hour reassuring someone before you give them feedback. It does mean you should understand the relationship you are bringing into the room. If trust is strong, focus on making sure the message is understood and that they know you still believe in their abilities. Everyone makes mistakes, and one issue is just that, one issue.
If trust is weak or untested, be more deliberate about explaining why you are having the conversation and what you want it to accomplish. Then take some additional time to reassure them that this is a behavior concern, not a worth concern. You might say, "I know you want to do well, and that is why I am sharing this today. I want to see you succeed, and you are a valued member of the team. Let me know how I can help make sure the improvement we discussed happens."
Either way, be clear about what kind of conversation it is. If this is coaching, say that. If it is a formal corrective conversation, say that too. Do not offer false reassurance just to make the meeting easier. The person deserves to know what kind of conversation they are in.
Use questions to stay in the same conversation
This is where good questions help. Before you offer a solution or explain your conclusion, ask what they heard and how they are seeing the situation. Questions such as these can keep you in the same conversation:
"What is your understanding of what we are talking about?"
"How are you hearing this?"
"What part of this feels unclear?"
"What do you think needs to happen next?"
Then listen to the answer. If you are not sure you understand it, ask another question. Repeat back what you heard in your own words and check whether you got it right. As an example, "So you understood the expectation, but the priority changed after you had already started, and you were not sure which commitment mattered most. Did I get that right?"
That is not agreeing with every explanation. It is making sure you understand it before you decide what to do with it. Once the person knows you heard them, they are more likely to hear you. You may still need to bring the conversation back to the behavior: "I understand why that was frustrating. We still need to talk about the missed commitment and what needs to be different next time." The empathy does not replace accountability. It simply makes accountability easier for the other person to hear.
Prepare before you walk in
Before you walk in, make sure you can answer these questions:
What did I see, and when did it happen?
What outcome am I hoping for from this conversation?
Is this coaching, corrective feedback, or a formal warning?
Why does it matter to the person, the team, or the business?
What might this person believe the conversation means about them?
What do they need to understand before they can hear the feedback?
What needs to change from this point forward?
What will I do if it happens again?
During the conversation, keep checking that you are still meeting in the same place. Ask what they are hearing. Ask what questions they have. If they explain something you did not know, make room for it before you return to your conclusion. You can change your understanding of the situation without abandoning the standard.
Preparing this way keeps you from turning the conversation into a general complaint about the person. It also makes it easier to stay calm if the other person is surprised or defensive. Expect that reaction going in, so you are not caught off guard if the conversation takes a turn you didn't plan for. Stick to what happened, explain why it matters, make sure they understand what kind of conversation they are in, and give them a clear way forward.
Why it is worth getting right
Tough conversations can strengthen relationships and the team as a whole. Team members look to the leader to set expectations and to enforce them. If enforcement becomes negotiable or uneven, it starts to break down the team and the positive dynamics that come from working together. Preparing, thinking ahead about how the person might react, and being specific go a long way toward making these conversations meaningful and helpful.
What have been the best ways you've prepared for tough conversations?
Get leadership tips and new articles you can use directly to your inbox. Join the thousands of other leaders continuing their leadership development journey at Effective Retail Leader.com.
DISCLAIMER: I participate in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide me with fees by linking to Amazon.com and other sites.